Political and legal preconditions for supervision and control over the observance of factory law in Ukraine

Requisitos previos político-legales para la formación de la institución de supervisión y control del cumplimiento de la legislación fabril en Ucrania

• Halyna Lavryk Poltava University of Economics and Trade. Poltava, Ukraine. https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5331-4327
• Halyna Terela Poltava University of Economics and Trade. Poltava, Ukraine. https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5102-7068
• Viktoriia Orel Poltava University of Economics and Trade. Poltava, Ukraine. https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1474-1614

DOI: https://doi.org/10.46398/cuestpol.4073.35

Keywords: supervision, control, factory legislation, factory inspections, ideology

Abstract

The objective consists in the investigation of the mental, domestic and cosmovisive requirements for the formation of factory legislation and the institution of supervision and control over its observance; to discover the ideological basis of the social reform of intersubjective relations, the formation of ideas on the content of the right to work in political and legal thought and, thus, to be able to reveal the particularities of the organizational and legal model of supervision and control in the imperial period. Taking into account that legislation serves as an indicator of the legal materialization of ideas and values, to determine the political and legal requirements for the establishment of the institution of supervision and control of compliance with factory legislation, an axiological approach, a set of general criteria and special legal methods are used.It is concluded that the period initiated by the bourgeois revolutions was accompanied by the search for an ideological justification for the rapid changes and transformations in the development of social relations in the field of free labor. The factory inspections of the Russian and Austro-Hungarian Empires, created on the basis of the English model, were characterized by the ability to monitor compliance with factory legislation.

References

ANDRIEVSKY, Ivan. 1871. Police Law. Volume I. Introduction and Part 1, Security Police. Saint Petersburg, Russia.

BEZOBRAZOV, Vladimir. 1888. Observations and considerations of V. P. Bezobrazov regarding the operation of new factory legalizations and factory inspection. Saint Petersburg, Russia.

BELYAVSKY, Nikolay. 1904. Police law (lecture notes). Yuriev. Russia.

BOSTAN, Ludmila; BOSTAN, Sergiy. 2008. History of the State and the Rights of Foreign Countries. Kiev, Ukraine.

BYKOV, Alexander. 1909. Factory legislation and its development in Russia. Saint Petersburg, Russia.

VAVZHENCHUK, Sergiy. 2016. Protection of labor rights of the worker: the worker. Kharkiv, Ukraine.

GREAT UKRAINIAN LAW ENCYCLOPEDIA: 20. 2017.Vol. 2: Philosophy of law. Kharkiv, Ukraine.

THE HIGHEST APPROVED OPINION OF THE STATE COUNCIL. 1882. «On minors working in factories, plants and manufactures» In: Complete collection of laws of the Russian Empire. Vol. II. № 931.

THE HIGHEST APPROVED OPINION OF THE STATE COUNCIL. 1886 p. «On the hiring of workers in factories, plants and manufactures and on the mutual relations of manufacturers and workers» In: Complete collection of laws of the Russian Empire. Collection 3. Vol. VI. № 3769.

HESSEN, Vladimir. 1902. From lectures on police law, given in the 1901-1902 academic year at the Alexander Military Law Academy. Saint Petersburg, Russia.

GOROBETS, Kostyantyn. 2012. Axiosphere of law and components.Abstract of PhD Dissertation. University «Odessa Law Academy». Odesa, Ukraine.

GRANDNER, Margarete. 1994. «ConservativeSocialPoliticsinAustria, 1880-1890» In: Working Paper. No. 2, рр. 1-19.


GRYSHCHUK, Oksana. 2019. Philosophy of constitutional values: monograph. Kyiv, Ukraine.

DONCHENKO, Olena. 2016. “Features of the spread of European liberal ideas in Ukraine in the second half of the nineteenth century” In: Current issues of domestic jurisprudence. No. 6. Vol. 2. pp. 3-6.

ELISTRATOV, Arkady. 1910. Textbook of Russian administrative law. Handbook for lectures. Issue I. Moscow, Russia.

ZHELEZNOV, Vladimir. 1903. “A Century of Factory Law (in the Anglo-Saxon Lands)” In: Readings in the Historical Society of Nestor the Chronicler. Book 17. pp. 55-56.

ZHYGALKIN, Ivan. 2016. The system of principles of labor law in the formation of the legal doctrine of Ukraine. PhD Thesis. Volodymyr Dahl East Ukrainian National University. Lugansk, Ukraine.

KOTLYAREVSKY, Sergei. 1915. Power and law. The problem of the rule of law. Moscow, Russia.

KOCHETKOVA, Lyudmila. 2008. “Lorenz von Stein’s Theory of the Welfare State” In: Philosophy and Society. No. 3, pp. 70-79.

KRUGLASHOV, Anatoly. “State, nation, people. Mykhailo Drahomanov on the National Development of Ukraine” In: Bulletin of the Academy of Sciences of Ukraine. No. 2, pp. 22-32.

KUPRIYANOVA, Liubov. The “working question” in Russia in the second half of the XIX – early XX centuries. Available online. In: http://www.hist.msu. ru/Labour/Article/Kupriyanova.htm. Consultation date: 10/12/2021.

LEVYNSKY, Volodymyr. 1914. Essay on the development of the labor movement in Galicia with a foreword by Lev Yurkevich. Kyiv, Ukraine.

LOKHOVA, Irina. 2016. Social policy of Germany and Austria in the last third of the XIX – early XX centuries. PhD Thesis. Federal State Budgetary Educational Institution of Higher Education «North Ossetian State University named after Kost Levanovich Khetagurov». Russia.

MALINOVA, O. Yu. (n/y). Development of the concept of human rights and legal regulation of labor relations. Available online. In: http://www.strategy- spb.ru/Koi-8/Proekt/humanrights/Tezis/tez_7.html. Consultationdate: 10/12/2021.

MATERIALS ON THE PUBLICATION OF THE LAW June 2, 1897 on the limitation and distribution of working time in the establishments of the factory industry. 1905. St. Petersburg, Russia.

MIROSHNICHENKO, Maria. 2012. Genesis of the legal system of Ukraine: theoretical and methodological aspect. PhD Thesis. Administration of the international university for the development of the people «Ukraine». Ukraine.

MOHL, Robert. 1871. The science of the police on the basis of the legal state. Issue I. St. Petersburg, Russia.

NISSELOVICH, Leopold. 1883. History of factory and plant law of the Russian Empire. Part 1. St. Petersburg, Russia.

PALIENKO, Nikolay. 1906. «The rule of law and constitutionalism» In: Bulletin of Law. Book 1. pp. 127-163.

PODOLYNSKY, Sergiy. 1880. Crafts and factories in Ukraine. Geneva, 1880. Switzerland.

POSSE, Vladimir. 1906. The history of labor legislation in Russia: an essay. Saint Petersburg, Russia.

ROBITNICHIY RUKH IN UKRAINE (1885-1894): collection of documents and materials. 1990. Kyiv, Ukraine.

DICTIONARY OF THE UKRAINIAN LANGUAGE. Academic Interpretive Dictionary (1970-1980): in 11 volumes. Available online. In: http://sum. in.ua/. Consultation date: 10/12/2021.

TAL, Leo. 1918. Essays on Industrial Labor Law. Moscow, Russia.

FACTORY LAWS. Collection of laws, orders and clarifications on Russian factory law. 1909. St. Petersburg, Russia.

KHOLOD, Yuriy. 2006. «Legal Power: Theoretical Construction and Practice (Historical Excursion)» In: Bulletin of Kharkiv National University of Internal Reference. No. 34, рp. 11-16.

KHOLOD, Yuriy. 2006. «Factory legislation of the Russian Empire at the 19th century – on the ear of the 20th century» In: Bulletin of Kharkiv National University of Internal Reference. No. 32, рр. 175-182.

CENTRAL STATE HISTORICAL ARCHIVE OF UKRAINE (CDIAC OF UKRAINE). Fund 574. Description 1. Case 205, pp. 58-59.

STEIN, Lorenz. 1874. The doctrine of government and the law of government with a comparison of the literature and legislation of France, England and Germany. Saint Petersburg, Russia.

YURKEVYCH, Pamphil. 2001. History of Philosophy of Law. Philosophy of law. Philosophical diary. Ed. 3. Kyiv, Ukraine.

YAKOVYUK, Ivan. 2000. The social state: questions of theory and ways of its formation: PhD Thesis. Yaroslav the Wise National Law Academy of Ukraine. Ukraine.